Havard wrote:Simple answer: Neither.
...we need a bespoke The Vale
forum at The Piazza then?
Havard wrote:The Vale is a mini-setting featured in the 1999 D&D Starter Set Boxed Set and accompanying modules. Two modules were published, labelled D&D Fast-Play Game, to be used with this Boxed Set. The system used is nothing like 3rd Edtion.
I would compare it to a cross between BECMI and AD&D. It uses descending Armor Class (lower is better) and saving throws are rolled above your score, rather than against a DC set by cicumstances. Most likely, the designers used AD&D as a starting point, but wanted to simplify things to make the game feel more like BECMI in its ease to play for beginners. I believe these are the last products to carry a logo saying "Dungeons & Dragons" (without the "Advanced") before the release of 3rd edition.
As far as I have been able to find out there are no references to a greater setting beyond the tiny valley containing a handful of adventuring locations and the town named Haven.
I do wonder at these "starter sets" that have had both bespoke rules and bespoke campaign settings. I'm not sure what they were supposed to achieve with any customers they pulled in, as they don't seem to be stepping stones that lead towards more established product lines.
I'd be interested to find out more about how this was designed. Was it someone's personal campaign world? Was it built for the product? Did the designer actually locate it somewhere (like Mystara) but exclude that from the final product?
Havard wrote:There is another famous town called Haven in Mystara (from B3), but I guess this is such a generic name that it could be a coincindence.
I saw the same thing with the planet Falx and the earlier Falx that Frank Mentzer created.
But, it might be interesting to look at Mystara's Haven to see if it could fit.
Havard wrote:For one of my Thunder Rift maps, I had the idea of including those locations from The Vale Setting, since they are so few anyway, and because I was looking for more ideas to expand on Thunder Rift. Looking back, I have mixed feelings about that. I still prefer using The Vale as part of Mystara, but I might place it somewhere else, perhaps in Norwold or in Karameikos around Haven from B3.
I guess that, if it fits with the other Haven, it might make more sense to merge the two.
Where did you think was a good place to stick this stuff in Thunder Rift? Did you have a big empty area?