Havard wrote:From what I understand, some products published by JG in the 1970s and 1980s were not explicitly identified as part of the Wilderlands Setting untill the release of the D20 Wilderlands Line. Can anyone confirm that this is correct? Which settings/products fall into this category?
Given the philosophy they had, that the setting isn't what they publish but what the Judge SAYS it is, it wouldn't much matter if anything was given a specific location in the Wilderlands or not. If the DM wants it in the WIlderlands - it's part of the WIlderlands. If the DM DOESN'T want something in his/her WIlderlands - even if it says it is
- then it ISN'T. They were reasonably adamant about that approach - that ANYTHING in the published setting is still subject to the DM's approval, end-of-story. They wanted to fully support that DM authority, not overrule it or undermine it. You just can't rules-lawyer a Judges Guild Judge.